International Women's Day
>> Tuesday, March 8, 2011
In the West, International Women’s Day doesn’t mean much any more. It’s little more than a marketing opportunity for businesses, or an excuse for the last remnants of women’s grievance groups to keep griping.
"For the free, educated and affluent, welcome to the century of women."Margaret Wente; Globe & Mail. 07-March-2011.
There ya go - it's all over but for the whiners and gripers. We won; the war is over.
What? Did you miss the memo? Yeah, me too.
Wente, in her article, points to a few stories & statistics to support her argument. Women now outnumber men in many university programs, for example. Oh, and the outrage over Robert Dewar, the Manitoba judge that recently put his foot in his mouth during a rape case - that's another indication that we're all good now.
Great - but shall we ignore the fact that even so, the gap between men's & women's wages is going in the wrong direction? We never actually did get to parity, even though the rhetoric is that we did and are.
In 2003, women working on a full-time, full-year basis had average earnings of $36,500 - 71% of what men made [StatsCan ].
Neither Canada (22%) or the US (16%) has a particularly impressive number of women in parliment (2009)
In Canada unpaid work is estimated to be worth up to $319 billion in the money economy or 41% of GDP; globally the numbers skyrocket to $11 trillion US. Most unpaid work in Canada and around the world is performed by women. [UNPAC]
Women are more likely to live in poverty (Leaf), to be subjected to violence and don't even get me started on the challenges faced by Aboriginal women, or women with disabilities or mental illnesses, or....
We have made significant gains in some areas though - women are, for example, the fastest-growing population in prisons in both Canada and the US. And there are a whole lot more homeless women now - there's something to be proud of, eh?
Obviously, women have made progress in many western - or northern - or developed - (pick your term of choice) countries. For a time - and this is the point that people like Wente (and Palin and numerous other highly public anti-feminists) seem to have gotten stuck on - it even looked as though the war had indeed been won, or nearly so.
But with the rise of neoliberalism and the erosion of the welfare state, the gains that had been made have not stuck and we are now, in fact, heading in the wrong direction.... but shhhh... we are not supposed to notice! We are supposed to believe - as Wente obviously does - that it's all good now ... no more need for griping; we should celebrate.
Apparently she doesn't read the rest of the Globe & Mail ... or pay attention to what is going on around her either. Me, I would think that someone paid to write opinion columns for a major national newspaper should have a clue about what the current government is doing, for example... but hey, what do I know... I obviously missed the memo.
Maybe it's a day to celebrate International Women.
I found it very frustrating to read Wente's article especially in juxtaposition to all the strong women's day content elsewhere. This kind of ignorance and apathy is inexcusable in an educated women with her power of influence. pointing out the enrollment rates without contrasting them to wage gaps is not only useless, it is misleading, and siting judge Dewar's comments as evidence of female empowerment is idiotic.
She came off as flippant and ignorant, especially when compared with the sister article by Stephanie Nolan 'a long way to go'.
That is definitely a much more balanced and sourced article.
In much of the world, gains in women’s rights elude a silent majority
Thank goodness!
Another that I very much appreciated was Happy International Women's Day: You are Beautiful on rabble.ca.
Perception is an evil thing. Now anyone complaining about unfair treatment will have to face the sort of, "well, this official seeming op-ed piece by a WOMAN says different." Great.
I've already seen it happen with other ideas, like global warming and racial prejudice. If we just deny it, we can all feel better about ourselves.
Hey, you won a manga. If you want it (or you don't) let me know.